← QGrid_DONCHIAN_ATR_ADX_Anti

QGrid_DONCHIAN_ATR_ADX_Anti — performance

Unguarded: WARN · 1 warnGuarded: WARN · 1 warnQuantGridgunbot-quant

BTCUSDT · 2026-08-13 01:50 → 2026-09-12 01:50 UTC (30 days) · 0.03% fee + 2 bps slippage · 1,000 quote, one figure for every cell

The same document for both runs of the same measurement — first as the strategy ships, then with the break-even guard. Everything else about the two runs is identical.

As it ships WARN · 1 warn

Exits: the strategy's own exits, stops included

Return

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 0.10% 5.05% 9.78% 7.87% 8.81%
3m 0.22% 2.56% 5.77% 6.14% 7.40%
5m 0.07% 3.95% 9.97% 7.32% 6.89%

Edge vs buy and hold

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m -21.78% -16.83% -12.10% -14.01% -13.07%
3m -21.64% -19.30% -16.09% -15.72% -14.46%
5m -21.76% -17.87% -11.86% -14.51% -14.94%

Max drawdown

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 3.07% 4.57% 5.61% 4.06% 4.85%
3m 2.91% 4.59% 5.57% 4.02% 4.93%
5m 2.83% 4.39% 5.27% 3.77% 4.56%

Sharpe

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 0.16 2.59 3.73 4.12 3.89
3m 0.28 1.47 2.37 3.32 3.38
5m 0.13 2.30 4.07 3.97 3.17

Time in market

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 87.91% 98.91% 99.06% 99.07% 99.09%
3m 97.70% 98.94% 98.97% 98.51% 98.49%
5m 78.94% 97.60% 99.04% 98.26% 98.48%

Round trips

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 72 116 82 50 39
3m 40 73 44 27 20
5m 17 55 45 23 18

Win rate

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 76.39% 92.24% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
3m 77.50% 83.56% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
5m 94.12% 83.64% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%

Buy and hold, same window

Timeframe Buy and hold
1m 21.88%
3m 21.86%
5m 21.83%

Realised vs unrealised

Trade statistics — win rate, profit factor, average trade — count closed round trips only. Where realised and unrealised disagree in sign, those statistics describe a minority of the money: winners were closed and losers were held.

Cell Realised Unrealised Total
1m calm 27.06 -26.03 1.03
1m cautious 91.61 -41.06 50.55
1m medium 149.49 -51.70 97.79
1m bold 114.29 -35.58 78.71
1m aggressive 129.04 -40.97 88.07
3m calm 26.75 -24.57 2.18
3m cautious 65.36 -39.77 25.58
3m medium 108.60 -50.93 57.67
3m bold 96.64 -35.27 61.36
3m aggressive 104.13 -30.17 73.97
5m calm 24.15 -23.48 0.67
5m cautious 77.15 -37.60 39.55
5m medium 147.43 -47.74 99.69
5m bold 106.68 -33.46 73.21
5m aggressive 100.29 -31.39 68.90

Every number on this page is read from the run record that produced it — the audit pipeline writes the page and the record together, so the two cannot drift apart.

With the break-even guard WARN · 1 warn

Exits: no exit below average entry plus fees, stops included

Return

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 0.45% 5.03% 9.78% 7.87% 8.81%
3m 0.48% 3.13% 5.77% 6.14% 7.40%
5m 0.07% 3.63% 9.97% 7.32% 6.89%

Edge vs buy and hold

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m -21.44% -16.85% -12.10% -14.01% -13.07%
3m -21.38% -18.73% -16.09% -15.72% -14.46%
5m -21.76% -18.20% -11.86% -14.51% -14.94%

Max drawdown

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 2.98% 4.56% 5.61% 4.06% 4.85%
3m 2.84% 4.56% 5.57% 4.02% 4.93%
5m 2.83% 4.28% 5.27% 3.77% 4.56%

Sharpe

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 0.46 2.56 3.73 4.12 3.89
3m 0.54 1.76 2.37 3.32 3.38
5m 0.13 2.12 4.07 3.97 3.17

Time in market

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 83.96% 98.91% 99.06% 99.07% 99.09%
3m 88.10% 98.94% 98.97% 98.51% 98.49%
5m 78.95% 96.53% 99.04% 98.26% 98.48%

Round trips

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 69 102 82 50 39
3m 38 63 44 27 20
5m 17 45 45 23 18

Win rate

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
3m 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
5m 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%

What the guard refused

Every exit whose net proceeds would have fallen below the position's average entry price plus fees was refused. That includes every stop-loss, because a stop is by definition below entry.

The guard does not remove those losses. It converts them from realised losses into an open position, so the trade statistics improve by construction while the account may not. Read this table with the realised/unrealised split below, never with the win rate alone.

calm cautious medium bold aggressive
1m 311 of 380 (82%) 620 of 722 (86%) 0 of 82 (0%) 0 of 50 (0%) 0 of 39 (0%)
3m 488 of 526 (93%) 1,273 of 1,336 (95%) 0 of 44 (0%) 0 of 27 (0%) 0 of 20 (0%)
5m 2 of 19 (11%) 77 of 122 (63%) 0 of 45 (0%) 0 of 23 (0%) 0 of 18 (0%)

Buy and hold, same window

Timeframe Buy and hold
1m 21.88%
3m 21.86%
5m 21.83%

Realised vs unrealised

Trade statistics — win rate, profit factor, average trade — count closed round trips only. Where realised and unrealised disagree in sign, those statistics describe a minority of the money: winners were closed and losers were held.

Cell Realised Unrealised Total
1m calm 29.92 -25.47 4.46
1m cautious 91.29 -41.02 50.27
1m medium 149.49 -51.70 97.79
1m bold 114.29 -35.58 78.71
1m aggressive 129.04 -40.97 88.07
3m calm 29.26 -24.48 4.78
3m cautious 71.15 -39.86 31.29
3m medium 108.60 -50.93 57.67
3m bold 96.64 -35.27 61.36
3m aggressive 104.13 -30.17 73.97
5m calm 24.21 -23.48 0.73
5m cautious 73.45 -37.18 36.28
5m medium 147.43 -47.74 99.69
5m bold 106.68 -33.46 73.21
5m aggressive 100.29 -31.39 68.90

Every number on this page is read from the run record that produced it — the audit pipeline writes the page and the record together, so the two cannot drift apart.

What the guard is, and what a better number under it means. The break-even guard refuses any exit below average entry plus fees. It cannot improve a strategy's judgement — it can only stop it selling at a loss, which means holding the position instead. Across the pack that turns a strategy that churned into one that buys and waits: trade counts collapse and time in market rises towards 100%. In a window where the asset itself rose, that reads as a much better return while being strictly less of a strategy.

So read the return next to round trips, time in market and edge vs buy and hold. The last of those is the one that matters: not one strategy in this matrix beat simply holding the asset, in either run.

Ignore the win rate and the profit factor under the guard. Both count closed trades only, and the guard closes nothing at a loss — in all 101 guarded runs the number of losing closed trades is exactly zero. So the win rate goes to 100% and the profit factor becomes undefined for arithmetic reasons, while the losses sit in the position that is still open. The unrealised row is where they went.